logo.jpg (9891 bytes)

 papa.jpg (16216 bytes) 

 logo2.jpg (8251 bytes)   

 

menu2.jpg (12527 bytes)  Welcome to Papa's Corner! The eclectic column by Rex Stocklin! 

Pictures, memorabillia, reviews, personal treasures, & rarities! 

All from the vast vault of Papa Frog 

All opinions are those of Papa Frog.

 

Click Here For Papa's Review of The David Pack Go Fish Show

Click Here for the previous "Papa's Corner"

Review of the Joe Puerta's Sunken City  Show @ The Normandie Casino-June 19,1998

Since the set list is pretty much the same as the first concert (with one notable exception), I won't do a song by song review here. Because frankly these Sunken City songs are all pretty well executed and wonderful compositions or better than faithful executions of older Ambrosia material. I will note various impressions I had during the show that stood out. I've gotta say that seeing Joe & his band twice now, that I've come full circle as to who I think is the best songwriter and the best singer in Ambrosia. Also, while Ambrosia is the more creative of the two bands, they are equivalent in talent load and SC is currently the one who has the most fun and it is infectious! Disclaimer: All referenced sound links are to representative clips and not necessarily excerpts from this show.

The casino is heralded as a bit of Vegas in Los Angeles. It was smoke-filled and loaded with blue-collar, ethnic and elderly folk who either care not for the trek to or stress of the real McCoy just a hundred or so miles away or can't afford to do so. But hey! Money is money and dreams are dreams. Mine lay in the back of the room in the showroom. This was to be a taste of the upcoming trip to the Arizona Chaz show. The room was at once cozy and cheesy (I searched high & low for the poker-playing dogs on black velvet paintings, but none were found), draped in whorehouse red with Disneyesque high society "statuary" in the faux 2nd floor box seats overlooking the stage that I half-expected to come alive in that animatronic Bear Country Jamboree way. Festivities erupted after a short warm-up by San Pedro stand-up comedian Robert Aguayo giving a mix of tepid audience banter, inside San Pedro jokes and quite inspired bits (the drive-thru signage routine for the illiterate was "choice"). Then, like Batman, pow...biff...zowie....Sunken City was unveiled, this time more formally via a red satin curtain, than the more casual gig at Sacred Grounds. Talk about classing up a joint!!

SCaguyo.jpg (17515 bytes)
Robert Aguayo giving a mix of tepid audience banter

A "Freak Show" (http://www.rth1.com/freak.rm) began the set sans Jerry Springer and via an a capella intro that belied the upcoming intense tune. It sounded as good as always, but Buck was ever so sweet & soulful on baritone sax. He put David Sanborn to shame and easily matches Raphael Ravenscroft's saxophonic intensity. Once again Gordon Sumner (aka Sting) surprised the audience with a walk-on. He was a master shape-shifter though & pretty damn good at sleight of hand because damn if he didn't look like Joe Puerta and then again like Eddie Callen. I mentioned this impression in my review of the first show, but I am stunned by these vocalists consistency and complimentary harmonies. Like Sting double-tracked. I hope Joe doesn't feel slighted by this comparison, because in this reviewer's mind Sting, love him or hate him, is one of today's most gifted vocalists. Buck was magnificent on this number as well.

SCJOEintro.jpg (15707 bytes)SCbuck1.jpg (13191 bytes)
   Mr.Puerta arrives!                                             Buck was ever so sweet & soulful on sax.

Next was "Let Me Down Slow" (http://www.rth1.com/letdwn.rm) with even more sexy, bluesy sax and pretty Joe bass lines featuring the chameleon-like Callen sounding this time like a blend of Gino Vannelli and Bloodrock's Warren Ham.

SCeddie1.jpg (15219 bytes)
Eddie Callen belts it out!

"Kamikaze" (http://www.rth1.com/kamikaze.ra) is maybe the most quirky & musically imaginative of Joe's Ambrosia songs. It was made for the virtuosity of Mike Keneally, who, apologies to Joe & the others, is THE walking highlight film of Sunken City shows. This young man can do it all. I bought his "Sluggo" CD off of him at the show and will, along with Joe, introduce y'all to this genius in a later post. Meanwhile check out his 2 websites for more info at http://www.rth1.com/bfd.htm & http://www.moosenet.com/keneally.html. For some Mike sound clips: http://www.immunerecords.com/keneally/index.htm. He again started the song out with tasty improvised metallic prog chops seguing fluidly to the familiar choppy & chiming chords of "Kamikaze".

SCmike1.jpg (17010 bytes)
The AMAZING Mike Keneally!

The next songs were the "Life Beyond L.A." tandem of "Art Beware" & "Apothecary". "Beware" proves that there is beauty to be found in dissonance with Joe, Mike, Jason & Eddie blending in that jazzy, not quite melodic vocal pastiche that only a band like Sunken City or Ambrosia can really handle. Let's see Hanson or Boyz II Men do THAT!!!. Buck's sax works fine in lieu of the harmonica (which Eddie can play wonderfully, too bad, I missed that sound here).


THE Keyboard Wizard-David Cutler Lewis!


"Apothecary" showcased Keneally's jazz roots which from the hollow-bodied sound of his guitar tone may be steeped in George Benson, Wes Montgomery, Barney Kessel and Joe Pass. Add this sound to his Zappa/Fripp style and you begin to see what a complex player  he is.

Brian's ethereally haunting cello solo was the "lead-in" to "Shape I'm In". This was singularly the most intriguing sound of the night. Imagine McKendree Spring using a cello instead of their violin for their signature "God Bless the Conspiracy" ambient sound. Sort of Philip Glass by way of Alan Parsons. "Shape I'm In" was okay and as in the first show Eddie filled in for Royce's pipes like a trooper. Why isn't this guy on a contract?

SCbrian1.jpg (12567 bytes)
Brian's ethereally haunting cello solo

Keneally swapped his ever-present fluorescent green (make unknown) guitar for a seat at the electric keys. A delicious Windham Hilly solo ensued. My wife, who is a classically-trained pianist, just looked at me with jaw agape. And to think that wannabes like John Tesh get the attention. Mike could melt the metronome off of that mediocre Mendelssohn's mellowtron (sic). This served as an intro to the magnificent "Cowboy Star", which seemed very a propos given the saloony feel of this joint. Can you imagine what it will feel like at Arizona Charlie's, a truly shitkickin', tumbleweedin' establishment?

SCmikekeys1.jpg (14447 bytes)
Keneally wows with a Steve Vai guitar-to-piano transcription!

The show's tenor calmed a bit as Buck flauted us into "Fool Like Me" and then to "Harvey", two of the best examples of Joe's acoustic range. Gordon Lightfoot, eat your heart out. A great clip of the "Cowboy Star"/"Fool Like Me" tandem is at http://www.rth1.com/cowboy.ra.

SCbuckflute.jpg (13174 bytes)SCjoe2.jpg (13200 bytes)
Buck:Fool Like Me flautist                              Joe: acoustic excellence!

The evening's biggest surprise was yet another Beatle rendition. This time it was "She's Leaving Home". Joe sang lead from a lyric sheet (you don't want to cover the fab 4 and look foolish not knowing the words. As it is he did the last phrase repeating the "She's Leaving Home" refrain and not singing the original last refrain which is "She's Having Fun". I chalk that up to interpreter's license and not bungling.) The cello & harmonies did justice to the original arrangement and made one think that Sir George Martin would make a cameo. It was in this song that my postulate that Joe is the strongest & most versatile Ambrosia singer was cemented. He glid so effortlessly between falsetto & his luscious tenor, that I was astonished.


I listen to Mike doing the opening pretty trills on " and "I Wanna Know" and " and then the searing chords & chops in the song's main body and am amazed how he so deftly captures Dave's tone, velocity, texture, timbre & timing and still make it sound like Frank Zappa. Then he moves to a piece like " and "Holdin' On To Yesterday" and " and comes off all bluesy like, sultry & slinky a la Slowhand. I'd love to hear Mike do "Layla" or "White Room". He is at once Zappa, Vai & Fripp, all 3 not surprisingly major influences on his style. As I peruse my review of the inaugural Sunken City show, I see that I draw comparisons also to Adrian Belew, Eric Johnson & Marty Willson-Piper. In short this guy can sound like just about any known guitarist. The world's first guitar impressionist, maybe???

SCmike2.jpg (15264 bytes)
Can't touch this

Other notes: The venue only gave our fearless crew 90 minutes in which to unleash their powerful mojo. Thus crowd favorite "Mama Don't Understand" and personal favorite "Feels so Good to Win" had to be excised from the program.
The lighting was clumsy, but the sound more than made up for it. It would have been a definitive "live album" performance. Plus you could tell that the troupe had really gelled quite a bit from that first show. They sounded as if they'd been doing this for years.

It was great to see Chris North return for the encore songs "Nice Nice, Very Nice" (http://www.rth1.com/nice.ra) and "Holdin' On To Yesterday". He seems looser in the Sunken City setting than he does with Ambrosia. He actually punctuates his Godzilla-tinkles-the-ivories routine by upturning the portable organ console as if he is returning it to its upright position before landing. And it stays!!! This kind of theatrics has been absent since Kansas' Steve Walsh and ELP's Keith Emerson physically abused their organs onstage. Well at least he didn't chop it up & set fire to it a la Jimi & The Who.

SCmikechrisjoe.jpg (21177 bytes)
Mike, Chris "The ANIMAL" North, & Joe!


What else can I say? Trying to be as objective as possible, I think that each song in the set is a stellar piece of songwriting and the band is impeccably up to the chore of breathing life into them. Sort of Ambrosia II. I'd actually like to see if the other guys can write music too. Did I gloss over Joe & his talent? Well, he is one of the most tasteful, lyrical bass players I've ever heard. His voice is way too underappreciated and literally makes me shudder (not cringe, folks) every time I hear it. And, I cannot say this too much, the quintessential thinking man's songwriter with astute pop & jazz sensibilities. And a good-looking hunk of man (my wife made me say it, but I don't disagree)! But I thought you all knew all of that already :-)

SCjoemike.jpg (19548 bytes)SCjoe1.jpg (16635 bytes)
Joe & Mike: Mutual Respect!                        Joe, the quintessential thinking man's songwriter

For more of an idea & a different perspective of what Sunken City is all about, I refer you the excellent review of the first show at http://www.rth1.com/sunkenstory.htm.


the set list:

Freak Show
The Voice
Let Me Down Slow
Kamikaze
Art's Lament
Art Beware
Apothecary
Cello Intro
Shape I'm In
Piano Solo
Cowboy Star
Fool Like Me
Harvey
She's Leaving Home
Bad to Worse
Hopes and Dreams
I Wanna Know

the encores:

And Your Bird Can Sing
Nice Nice, Very Nice
Holdin' On To Yesterday

For a more detailed set list, see Bob's on the Sunken City site at http://www.rth1.com/normandie2.htm.

the players:

Joe Puerta on bass & lead vocals
David Cutler Lewis on keys
Mike Keneally on axes, keys, bass & lead vocals
"Buck" Ambrose Splescia on saxes
Eddie Callen on lead vocals
Jason Smith on drums & background vocals
Brian Asher on cello & bass
Chris North on organ


Joe, Rex, Chris, & the "legendary" Tom Trefethen!

Rex Stocklin

Pics by Pat

Check Back Often!!   

Return To travellers danse 

Home